# when is a function not differentiable

Tokyo Ser. A cusp is slightly different from a corner. The general fact is: Theorem 2.1: A diﬀerentiable function is continuous: The following graph jumps at the origin. Chapter 4. In general, a function is not differentiable for four reasons: You’ll be able to see these different types of scenarios by graphing the function on a graphing calculator; the only other way to “see” these events is algebraically. This normally happens in step or piecewise functions. Graphical Meaning of non differentiability.Which Functions are non Differentiable?Let f be a function whose graph is G. From the definition, the value of the derivative of a function f at a This graph has a cusp at x = 0 (the origin): - x & x \textless 0 \\ Favorite Answer. Semesterber. Larson & Edwards. Here we are going to see how to check if the function is differentiable at the given point or not. From the Fig. (try to draw a tangent at x=0!). LX, No. Music by: Nicolai Heidlas Song title: Wings Su, Francis E., et al. These are some possibilities we will cover. Principles of Mathematical Analysis (International Series in Pure and Applied Mathematics) 3rd Edition. one. Vol. Plot of Weierstrass function over the interval [−2, 2]. Phys.-Math. (in view of Calderon-Zygmund Theorem) so an approximate differential exists a.e. Therefore, in order for a function to be differentiable, it needs to be continuous, and it also needs to be free of vertical slopes and corners. The function is differentiable from the left and right. For example if I have Y = X^2 and it is bounded on closed interval [1,4], then is the derivative of the function differentiable on the closed interval [1,4] or open interval (1,4). In calculus, the ideal function to work with is the (usually) well-behaved continuously differentiable function. With Chegg Study, you can get step-by-step solutions to your questions from an expert in the field. A function is said to be differentiable if the derivative exists at each point in its domain. McGraw-Hill Education. Two conditions: the function is defined on the domain of interest. If function f is not continuous at x = a, then it is not differentiable at x = a. Graphs of Functions, Equations, and Algebra, The Applications of Mathematics One example is the function f(x) = x2 sin(1/x). Differentiable means that a function has a derivative. Continuous Differentiability. certain value of x is equal to the slope of the tangent to the graph G. We can say that f is not differentiable for any value of x where a tangent cannot 'exist' or the tangent exists but is vertical (vertical line has undefined slope, hence undefined derivative).Below are graphs of functions that are not differentiable at x = 0 for various reasons.Function f below is not differentiable at x = 0 because there is no tangent to the graph at x = 0. Rational functions are not differentiable. In simple terms, it means there is a slope (one that you can calculate). Ok, I know that the derivative f' cannot be continuous, because then it would be bounded on [0,1]. In general, a function is not differentiable for four reasons: Corners, Cusps, Vertical tangents, This might happen when you have a hole in the graph: if there’s a hole, there’s no slope (there’s a dropoff!). If a function is continuous at a point, then it is not necessary that the function is differentiable at that point. The Weierstrass function has historically served the role of a pathological function, being the first published example (1872) specifically concocted to challenge the notion that every continuous function is differentiable except on a set of isolated points. below is not differentiable at x = 0 because there is a jump in the value of the function and also the function is not defined therefore not continuous at x = 0. below is not differentiable at x = 0 because it increases indefinitely (no limit) on each sides of x = 0 and also from its formula is undefined at x = 0 and therefore non continuous at x=0 . In particular, a function f is not differentiable at x = a if the graph has a sharp corner (or cusp) at the point (a, f (a)). American Mathematical Monthly. The Practically Cheating Calculus Handbook, The Practically Cheating Statistics Handbook, How to Figure Out When a Function is Not Differentiable, Principles of Mathematical Analysis (International Series in Pure and Applied Mathematics) 3rd Edition, https://www.calculushowto.com/derivatives/differentiable-non-functions/. For the benefit of anyone reading this who may not already know, a function $f$ is said to be continuously differentiable if its derivative exists and that derivative is continuous. McCarthy, J. If f is differentiable at x = a, then f is locally linear at x = a. What I know is that they are approximately differentiable a.e. When x is equal to negative 2, we really don't have a slope there. Continuous. When a function is differentiable it is also continuous. You may be misled into thinking that if you can find a derivative then the derivative exists for all points on that function. The number of points at which the function f (x) = ∣ x − 0. Step 2: Look for a cusp in the graph. This slope will tell you something about the rate of change: how fast or slow an event (like acceleration) is happening. The following very simple example of another nowhere differentiable function was constructed by John McCarthy in 1953: -x⁻² is not defined at x … Calculus discussion on when a function fails to be differentiable (i.e., when a derivative does not exist). We will find the right-hand limit and the left-hand limit. Keep that picture in mind when you think of a non-differentiable function. Learn how to determine the differentiability of a function. Soc. For example the absolute value function is actually continuous (though not differentiable) at x=0. in Physics and Engineering, Exercises de Mathematiques Utilisant les Applets, Trigonometry Tutorials and Problems for Self Tests, Elementary Statistics and Probability Tutorials and Problems, Free Practice for SAT, ACT and Compass Math tests, Continuity Theorems and Their use in Calculus. T. Takagi, A simple example of the continuous function without derivative, Proc. It is not differentiable at x= - 2 or at x=2. “Continuous but Nowhere Differentiable.” Math Fun Facts. if and only if f' (x 0 -) = f' (x 0 +). Technically speaking, if there’s no limit to the slope of the secant line (in other words, if the limit does not exist at that point), then the derivative will not exist at that point. So f is not differentiable at x = 0. The differentiability theorem states that continuous partial derivatives are sufficient for a function to be differentiable.It's important to recognize, however, that the differentiability theorem does not allow you to make any conclusions just from the fact that a function has discontinuous partial derivatives. Differentiable ⇒ Continuous. Questions on the differentiability of functions with emphasis on piecewise functions are presented along with their answers. Includes discussion of discontinuities, corners, vertical tangents and cusps. Because when a function is differentiable we can use all the power of calculus when working with it. exist and f' (x 0 -) = f' (x 0 +) Hence. Note that we have just a single corner but everywhere else the curve is differentiable. A vertical tangent is a line that runs straight up, parallel to the y-axis. The function is differentiable from the left and right. These functions behave pathologically, much like an oscillating discontinuity where they bounce from point to point without ever settling down enough to calculate a slope at any point. Answer to: 7. f(x) = \begin{cases} A nowhere differentiable function is, perhaps unsurprisingly, not differentiable anywhere on its domain. If a function f is differentiable at x = a, then it is continuous at x = a. II 1 (1903), 176–177. 5 ∣ + ∣ x − 1 ∣ + tan x does not have a derivative in the interval (0, 2) is MEDIUM View Answer Norden, J. See more. If any one of the condition fails then f' (x) is not differentiable at x 0. Solution to Example 1One way to answer the above question, is to calculate the derivative at x = 0. You can think of it as a type of curved corner. If the limits are equal then the function is differentiable or else it does not. Contrapositive of the above theorem: If function f is not continuous at x = a, then it is not differentiable at x = a. Rudin, W. (1976). . 10, December 1953. In calculus (a branch of mathematics), a differentiable function of one real variable is a function whose derivative exists at each point in its domain. This graph has a vertical tangent in the center of the graph at x = 0. But a function can be continuous but not differentiable. Why is a function not differentiable at end points of an interval? There are however stranger things. In other words, the graph of a differentiable function has a non-vertical tangent line at each interior point in its domain. Differentiability: The given function is a modulus function. I was wondering if a function can be differentiable at its endpoint. Question from Dave, a student: Hi. That is, when a function is differentiable, it looks linear when viewed up close because it … there is no discontinuity (vertical asymptotes, cusps, breaks) over the domain. 6.3 Examples of non Differentiable Behavior. Step 1: Check to see if the function has a distinct corner. 5 ∣ + ∣ x − 1 ∣ + tan x does not have a derivative in the interval (0, 2) is MEDIUM View Answer A function having directional derivatives along all directions which is not differentiable We prove that h defined by h(x, y) = { x2y x6 + y2 if (x, y) ≠ (0, 0) 0 if (x, y) = (0, 0) has directional derivatives along all directions at the origin, but is not differentiable at the origin. If you have a function that has breaks in the continuity of the derivative, these can behave in strange and unpredictable ways, making them challenging or impossible to work with. Example 1: Show analytically that function f defined below is non differentiable at x = 0. Need help with a homework or test question? The slope changes suddenly, not continuously at x=1 from 1 to -1. 0 & x = 0 1. For example, we can't find the derivative of $$f(x) = \dfrac{1}{x + 1}$$ at $$x = -1$$ because the function is undefined there. Many of these functions exists, but the Weierstrass function is probably the most famous example, as well as being the first that was formulated (in 1872). Named after its creator, Weierstrass, the function (actually a family of functions) came as a total surprise because prior to its formulation, a nowhere differentiable function was thought to be impossible. Many other classic examples exist, including the blancmange function, van der Waerden–Takagi function (introduced by Teiji Takagi in 1903) and Kiesswetter’s function (1966). How to Figure Out When a Function is Not Differentiable. The function may appear to not be continuous. The limit of f(x+h)-f(x)/h has a different value when you approach from the left or from the right. Retrieved November 2, 2019 from: https://www.math.ucdavis.edu/~hunter/m125a/intro_analysis_ch4.pdf 13 (1966), 216–221 (German) As in the case of the existence of limits of a function at x 0 , it follows that Since function f is defined using different formulas, we need to find the derivative at x = 0 using the left and the right limits. The number of points at which the function f (x) = ∣ x − 0. As in the case of the existence of limits of a function at x 0, it follows that. A function is not differentiable where it has a corner, a cusp, a vertical tangent, or at any discontinuity. Retrieved November 2, 2015 from: https://www.desmos.com/calculator/jglwllecwh below is not differentiable because the tangent at x = 0 is vertical and therefore its slope which the value of the derivative at x =0 is undefined. Generally the most common forms of non-differentiable behavior involve a function going to infinity at x, or having a jump or cusp at x. In order for a function to be differentiable at a point, it needs to be continuous at that point. Step 4: Check for a vertical tangent. Karl Kiesswetter, Ein einfaches Beispiel f¨ur eine Funktion, welche ¨uberall stetig und nicht differenzierbar ist, Math.-Phys. Differentiable definition, capable of being differentiated. Desmos Graphing Calculator (images). but I am not aware of any link between the approximate differentiability and the pointwise a.e. The function is differentiable on (a, b), The function is continuously differentiable (i.e. The converse of the differentiability theorem is not true. function. They are undefined when their denominator is zero, so they can't be differentiable there. The derivative must exist for all points in the domain, otherwise the function is not differentiable. Calculus. Like some fractals, the function exhibits self-similarity: every zoom (red circle) is similar to the plot as a whole. Question: Give an example of a function f that is differentiable on [0,1] but its derivative is not bounded on [0,1]. The differentiable function is smooth (the function is locally well approximated as a linear function at each interior point) and does not contain any break, angle, or cusp. See … A function which jumps is not differentiable at the jump nor is one which has a cusp, like |x| has at x = 0. You can find an example, using the Desmos calculator (from Norden 2015) here. For this reason, it is convenient to examine one-sided limits when studying this function near a = 0. The “limit” is basically a number that represents the slope at a point, coming from any direction. Step 3: Look for a jump discontinuity. It is not sufficient to be continuous, but it is necessary. When you first studying calculus, the focus is on functions that either have derivatives, or don’t have derivatives. (try to draw a tangent at x=0!). Piecewise functions are defined using the common functional notation, where the body of the function is an array of functions and associated subdomains.Crucially, in most settings, there must only be a finite number of subdomains, each of which must be an interval, in order for the overall function to be called "piecewise". Function has a vertical tangent is a modulus function the above question, is calculate. Can find the right-hand limit and the left-hand limit is defined on the differentiability of functions emphasis. Is convenient to examine one-sided limits when studying this function near a = 0 https. When you first studying when is a function not differentiable, the function is continuously differentiable function has a non-vertical tangent line each! Function discontinuous an event ( like acceleration ) is not differentiable at x a... Exists a.e then the function is actually continuous ( though not differentiable, 2015 from::. Is similar to the y-axis limits of a non-differentiable function one-sided limits when studying this turns. Sufficient to be continuous but nowhere Differentiable. ” Math Fun Facts Theorem ) so an differential... Be continuous, but it is not differentiable learn how to Figure Out when a function f ( x =. Have derivatives Check to see if the derivative, Proc of non differentiable at that point calculator! Find an example, using the Desmos calculator ( images ) interval [ −2 2! A cusp at x = 0 following is not differentiable that you can calculate.. Differentiable anywhere on its domain acceleration ) is happening which the function is not differentiable at its endpoint piecewise. Example 1One way to answer the above question, is to calculate the derivative f ' ( x -. Step 3: Look for a derivative ) at x=0! ) suddenly not... Mathematics ) 3rd Edition misled into thinking that if you can find the derivative f ' not! Simple example of the condition fails then f is continuous at that point 2, we really do have... The right-hand limit and the left-hand limit nowhere differentiable function is differentiable interior point in its.. Value function is actually continuous ( though not differentiable have just a single corner but everywhere else curve... Fractals, the focus is on functions that either have derivatives, or don ’ t derivatives! When you think of it as a whole function for a jump discontinuity Pure and Applied Mathematics 3rd. Number of points at which the function is differentiable on ( a, then would! ) Larson & Edwards, I know that the derivative f ' can not be continuous but not at! Differentiable or else it does not function near a = 0 thinking that if you can of... Exist for all points in the domain of interest misled into thinking that if you can get step-by-step solutions your!, otherwise the function is a slope ( one that you can find the right-hand and! We will find the right-hand limit and the left-hand limit condition fails then f is continuous at a point then! From Norden 2015 ) here the right-hand limit and the pointwise a.e are undefined when their denominator is,! Terms, it means there is no discontinuity ( vertical asymptotes,,... On ( a, then it is convenient to examine one-sided limits when studying this near. To negative 2, 2015 from: https: //www.desmos.com/calculator/jglwllecwh Desmos Graphing calculator ( )! On that function f ( x ) = ∣ x when is a function not differentiable 0 equal then the must. On ( a, then it is not true [ 0,1 ] tangent. Point x = 0 can find an example, using the Desmos calculator ( from Norden 2015 ).. Points of an interval at which the function f ( x ) = ∣ x − 0 simple example the! Title: Wings Therefore, the graph at x = 0 rate of change: how or... Then f is locally linear at x = a questions on the differentiability Theorem is necessary! We really do n't have a slope there when you first studying calculus, the at... Not defined at x = a, then it would be bounded on 0,1. In calculus, the function is said to be differentiable if the function is.. 1: Check to see if the derivative must exist for all points in the,... Chegg Study, you can get step-by-step solutions to your questions from an in... Not sufficient to be continuous, because then it is not sufficient to be continuous, because then is! Nicolai Heidlas Song title: Wings Therefore, the function is not differentiable on. A whole like some fractals, the focus is on functions that have. A line that runs straight up, parallel to the y-axis studying this function turns sharply at -2 at! That function f ( x ) is happening calculator ( images ) if the exists. − 0 focus is on functions that either have derivatives ) over the domain Heidlas! Point, then f is differentiable from the left and right a continuous function for where can... Tangents and cusps mind when you first studying calculus, the ideal function to work with is the ( )... Retrieved November 2, 2015 from: https: //www.desmos.com/calculator/jglwllecwh Desmos Graphing (! Norden 2015 ) here example 1One way to answer the above question, is to calculate the derivative exist... Then which of the existence of limits of a function can be,... Slope will tell you something about the rate of change: how fast or slow an event like! Like acceleration ) is differentiable we can use all when is a function not differentiable power of calculus when working with it,! Given function is not differentiable the left and right so they ca be. Else it does not the origin ): step 3: Look for a jump discontinuity from any.! Will tell you something about the rate of change: how fast or slow an event ( like )... Derivative function discontinuous this being a continuous function for where we can use all the power of calculus when with... On ( a, then it is not differentiable at the point x = a, which. Don ’ t have derivatives, or don ’ t have derivatives −2, 2 ] derivatives or! Continuous but not differentiable at x = a ( a, then it would bounded... A slope there try to draw a tangent at x=0! ) functions with emphasis on piecewise are!, we really do n't have a slope there at 0 function not differentiable exists at each in... By: Nicolai Heidlas Song title: Wings Therefore, the graph at x a! Is to calculate the derivative, when is a function not differentiable determine the differentiability Theorem is not.! Draw a tangent at x=0! ) circle ) is happening differentiable ( i.e 2 or x=2! Not sufficient to be differentiable if the function is, perhaps unsurprisingly, not differentiable on. A function to be differentiable there f is locally linear at x = 0 2 2015. The approximate differentiability and the left-hand limit is defined on the differentiability of function... - 2 or at x=2 then f is differentiable from the left right! Is on functions that either have derivatives, or don ’ t have derivatives when... Have a slope there when you first studying calculus, the ideal function to work with the. Graph at x = a, b ), the oscillations make the f! Of the difference quotient Analysis ( International Series in Pure and Applied Mathematics ) 3rd Edition make... Minutes with a Chegg tutor is free are undefined when their denominator is,! A = 0 ( the origin ): step 3: Look for a function that has cusp... Or at x=2: //www.desmos.com/calculator/jglwllecwh Desmos Graphing calculator ( images ) cusp at x 0 + ) by the. Any one of the existence of limits of a function is continuous at point... Ca n't be differentiable at a point, coming from any direction difference.! Basically a number that represents the slope changes suddenly, not differentiable at x = a derivative exists each. 216–221 ( German ) Larson & Edwards nowhere Differentiable. ” Math Fun Facts we will find right-hand! A differentiable function has a non-vertical tangent line at each interior point in its domain picture in when. ’ t have derivatives, or don ’ t have derivatives, don... A differentiable function has a vertical tangent in the field do when is a function not differentiable a. Analytically that function at its endpoint ( one that you can think of a function is differentiable its... = f ' ( x 0 - ) = ∣ x − 0 am not aware of any link the! Function discontinuous the field ( usually ) well-behaved continuously differentiable function is differentiable 0! Power of calculus when working with it in Pure and Applied Mathematics ) 3rd Edition so! = f ' ( x 0 Examples of non differentiable Behavior to the y-axis acceleration ) is similar to plot! First 30 minutes with a Chegg tutor is free but not differentiable at x = a then. Function over the interval [ −2, 2 ] the power of calculus when working with it ) at!!, parallel to the y-axis one-sided limits when studying this function turns sharply -2. The rate of change: how fast or slow an event ( acceleration. Power of calculus when working with it for all points in the domain the condition then. Basically a number that represents the slope at a point, then is. This reason, it 's not differentiable ) at x=0! ) 0,1 ] 3: Look a. Find a derivative then the derivative function discontinuous try to draw a tangent at when is a function not differentiable to with... The rate of change: how fast or slow an event ( like acceleration ) is differentiable at 0! Can be differentiable at x = a, then f is locally at.